Dating myths about interacial dating
This is not exactly a resounding victory for people claiming that the Dark Age had nothing wrong with it except slightly fewer records. It’s historical malpractice to call something “The Dark Ages”. So I assume you also raise a fuss whenever someone talks about Alexander the Great? Periclean Athens might not have been the most virtuous city, but it was certainly one with lasting accomplishments.Since it is so hard to judge the goodness or badness of historical figures, most of our claims of greatness are claims about impressiveness.Christian writers, including Petrarch himself, had long used traditional metaphors of ‘light versus darkness’ to describe ‘good versus evil’.Petrarch was the first to give the metaphor secular meaning by reversing its application. The “Time There Were Five Whole Emperors In A Row, None Of Whom Were Sadistic, Perverted, Or Insane, Which As Responsible Historians We Cannot Officially Call “Good”, But Which By The Standards Of Ancient Rome Is Seriously Super Impressive”. But if you only challenge the term “Dark Ages”, I feel like you’re doing the opposite of this suspension-of-judgment. ” you’re putting yourself in a position to judge historical eras, saying that maybe some of them were dark and others weren’t, but this particular one wasn’t.[Warning: non-historian arguing about history, which is always dangerous and sometimes awful.
But for you perhaps, if as I hope and wish you will live long after me, there will follow a better age. Jared Diamond thinks hunter-gatherers were freer and happier than anyone since.Likewise There Were No European Dark Ages, The Myth Of The Dark Ages, The Myth Of The “Dark Ages”, Medieval Europe: The Myth Of The Dark Ages, Busting The “Dark Ages” Myth, and of course smug Tumblr posts. Many people’s idea of medieval times is exaggerated. Suppose someone tells you that the middle of America contains the Great Plains, a very flat region.Not every scientist was burned at the stake, not everyone thought the world was flat and surrounded by space dragons, and the High Middle Ages were notable for impressive levels of material progress which in some cases outpaced the Classical World and which set the stage for the upcoming Renaissance (the continuity thesis). But I worry that as usual, this corrective to an overblown narrative of darkness has itself been overblown. But you know that actually there are lots of tall mountains, like the Rockies.Very few of the historical terms we use were invented by professional historians, and they are all necessarily based on that person’s opinion that it correctly describes the thing being described.I await people admitting that there was no Cold War, because who is George Orwell to think he can just name an era based on what he feels it was like? Historical periods get their names from random individuals reflecting on them; the names catch on if people agree that they fit. The term “Dark Ages” was originally just supposed to mean that there aren’t many sources describing it, not that the era was bad Nope, wrong.